The program designed to facilitate voluntary resettlement of people from the former Soviet republics has apparently stalled. At the time when the program was active very few took advantage of the opportunity to move to their historical homeland. One of the main reasons is problems with obtaining citizenship which takes years.
What are the challenges that these people are facing? Those who went through the process complain about endless layers of bureaucracy, the Federal Migration Service (FMS) requiring increasingly more documents that are not always possible to obtain. Many have difficulty translating documents from one of the national languages into Russian, as well as the fact that not all documents can be legally issued with ease.
Here is other evidence from the "martyrs:" "They refused to accept the documents from my mother, an old woman, whom I brought from Moldavia. She was born in Russia. She was denied documentation because in 2009 I had a small income, although 2009 has long passed."
"I live in Estonia, and, like my friends from Latvia, am not going to leave for Russia. Yes, we are second-class people here, we are forced to forget our native language and are called occupiers. But Russia is worse for us. We are nobody there. Our friends who have tried to settle down there came back, unable to bear the bureaucratic mayhem. This is why many prefer to leave for Europe, but not their historic homeland."
"It's time to reform the FMS. I obtained my citizenship, but if it were not for my aunt-colonel, who wrote a mean letter to the FMS, I would not have gotten it. What about those who do not have such relatives?"
While we enjoy banal phrases about the historical homeland welcoming the compatriots and it being a good solution for improving the demographics, they often think about moving to other countries. "In order to obtain Russian citizenship, a person must lose at least one year of their life in search of necessary information, collecting bills, standing in lines. At the same time they still have to manage to make money somehow. There has to be a separate department for the compatriots in the FMS. So far we have to watch some southerners who are getting into the offices bypassing the lines before our own eyes, while the Slavs are freezing in these lines."
"Is this the attitude we Russians deserve? The motherland greets us with humiliation, rudeness, lack of professionalism of the FMS employees, senseless endless lines for each piece of paper. They show you in every way that you are nobody and a slave! Where we came from we heard:" Suitcase - Train Station - Russia! "And here we hear:" We did not invite you here! "My son was so excited about going to Russia, and after such a reception he is asking," Mom, could be go to America instead?"
"I, being a Russian, was placed in the same condition with immigrants from the Caucasus republics, Central Asia and even Afghans. We are all equalized by the Russian laws which require eight years to complete the procedure for obtaining citizenship."
Some say that for those willing to fork out some extra money, the back door opens and then all problems are solved. One gets the impression that such bestial conditions are created deliberately in order that a person has no choice but to pay a bribe.
The FMS employees often recognize the issue and say that they simply unable to cope with the influx of visitors, especially considering that a great deal of time is spent not on the paperwork, but rather counseling the visitors.
In the West, things are different. It is believed that Israel and Germany have the most advanced legislation in terms of the work with compatriots and their descendants. The latter convene their own around the world, starting with the former Soviet republics and ending with South Africa and Latin america.
As for Israel, to obtain Israeli citizenship one does not have to be a full-blooded Jew. The total number of immigrants is in the millions, many of whom moved here because of the Jewish faith. The country is actively supporting this program. In Russia, the rules are somewhat different.
Alexandra Dokuchaeva, head of the diaspora department of the CIS Institute: "The situation is really depressing, and it is very, very difficult to obtain Russian citizenship. There are too many bureaucratic barriers. I know many cases when people have been waiting for citizenship for 10-15 years and all in vain. All attempts to simplify their lives fail. Zatulin and Pligin in the State Duma have repeatedly proposed amendments to the legislation that would simplify the procedure for obtaining citizenship for ethnic Russians, but they are still up in the air. Why? The conclusion suggests itself. Does Russia needs Russians with this approach? The authorities benefit from not getting Russians who will require some social security, pensions, etc. They need guest workers with no rights who are not asking for any rights and are willing to endure anything just to be able to work."